Blog
What Does Florida’s Dealing in Stolen Property Law Actually Prohibit?

What Does Florida’s Dealing in Stolen Property Law Actually Prohibit?

Understanding Stolen Property Charges in Florida

Key Takeaways: Under Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019, Florida’s dealing in stolen property law bans "trafficking" in property you knew or should have known was stolen. Trafficking covers selling, but also buying, receiving, or possessing goods with the intent to resell or transfer them, and attempts count too. The basic offense is a second-degree felony. It becomes a first-degree felony when the person also initiates, organizes, plans, finances, directs, manages, or supervises the theft. Prosecutors don’t have to prove you actually knew the goods were stolen. Jurors may draw inferences from facts such as a price far below market value or unexplained possession of recently stolen property, but a good explanation or proof of good faith may rebut them. Under Fla. Stat. ยง 812.025, the state can charge both theft and dealing for the same scheme, but the jury or judge may return a guilty verdict on only one. The original thief doesn’t need to be charged. Common defenses focus on lack of knowledge, no intent to resell, ownership disputes, identity, and constitutional violations, so getting legal help early can matter.

Florida’s dealing in stolen property law makes it a crime to "traffic in" property you knew, or should have known, was stolen. "Traffic" covers much more than selling. It also covers buying, receiving, possessing, or using goods if you intended to resell or pass them on. Under Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019(1), the basic offense is a second-degree felony, punishable by up to 15 years in prison. A first-degree version, punishable by up to 30 years, applies to people accused of initiating, organizing, planning, financing, directing, managing, or supervising a theft and then trafficking in what was taken.

If you are facing an accusation under this law, the sooner you get legal help, the more options you may have. Talk with The Law Offices of Robert David Malove before you speak with investigators. You can call 954-861-0384 or contact us now for a confidential review to start protecting your rights.

Pawn shop employee typing on laptop at wooden counter near barcode scanner

What the Dealing in Stolen Property Florida Statute Says

The statute has two main parts, and they carry different penalties. Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019(1) says that any person who "traffics in, or endeavors to traffic in, property that he or she knows or should know was stolen" commits a felony of the second degree. Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019(2) raises the charge to a first-degree felony for anyone who "initiates, organizes, plans, finances, directs, manages, or supervises" a theft and also traffics in the stolen property. You can read the full text of Florida Statute 812.019 on the Florida Senate’s website.

This law is not new. The legislature created it in 1977 and amended it in 1997, so a large body of case law shapes how prosecutors use it and how defense lawyers challenge it.

Provision Who It Targets Felony Level
Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019(1) Anyone who traffics or tries to traffic in stolen property Second degree
Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019(2) Anyone who initiates, organizes, plans, finances, directs, manages, or supervises a theft and also traffics in the property First degree

Key Terms That Define Trafficking in Stolen Property

Florida law defines each key word in this offense, and those definitions can affect whether a charge holds up. They appear in Fla. Stat. ยง 812.012.

What "Traffic" Means

Under Fla. Stat. ยง 812.012, "traffic" has two meanings. The first is to sell, transfer, distribute, dispense, or otherwise dispose of property. The second is to buy, receive, possess, obtain control of, or use property with the intent to sell, transfer, distribute, dispense, or otherwise dispose of it. The state can therefore charge someone who never completed a sale, if it claims they held the goods intending to resell or transfer them. Intent is often a weak point in the state’s case, because it usually must be inferred.

What Counts as "Stolen Property" and "Property"

"Stolen property" means property that has been the subject of any criminally wrongful taking. "Property" is just as broad: anything of value, including real property, tangible or intangible personal property, and services. Electronics, tools, jewelry, vehicle parts, gift cards, and even some digital assets could qualify.

Who Is a "Dealer in Property"

A "dealer in property" is any person in the business of buying and selling property. This matters for pawnshop workers, secondhand stores, online resellers, and flea market vendors. Florida law also allows certain inferences against dealers, for example when a dealer buys property without keeping required records. People in these businesses sometimes end up under investigation because an item they bought in good faith later turns out to be stolen.

The "Knew or Should Have Known" Standard

One of the most important features of this law is its knowledge requirement. Under Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019(1), prosecutors do not have to prove you actually knew the property was stolen. It may be enough to show that you should have known. The state often points to facts like these:

  • The price was far below market value
  • The seller had no receipt, box, or proof of ownership
  • Someone removed or altered the serial numbers
  • The sale took place at an odd time or in an unusual place
  • The seller told changing stories about where the item came from

These facts do not necessarily prove guilt on their own. A good deal is not, by itself, a crime. Fla. Stat. ยง 812.022 creates inferences about knowledge, such as possessing recently stolen property without a good explanation, or buying property well below fair market value. Jurors may draw these inferences but don’t have to, and you can rebut them. A defense attorney may present evidence that you acted in good faith, paid a fair price, or had no reasonable way to know the item’s history.

๐Ÿ’ก Pro Tip: Save every text message, marketplace listing, payment record, and receipt tied to the sale. Records showing you paid a fair price through a traceable method can help support a good-faith defense.

How Stolen Property Charges Interact With Theft Charges

Florida prosecutors often file theft and dealing in stolen property charges together for the same item. Fla. Stat. ยง 812.025 lets the state charge both in separate counts when they arise from one scheme or course of conduct. But the jury or judge may return a guilty verdict on only one of them, and Florida courts have treated convictions for both as error.

Why This Matters on Appeal

When a court wrongly convicts a defendant of both offenses, the defendant can sometimes raise the error after trial. A Florida Bar Journal analysis looks at how a defense lawyer’s failure to object to dual convictions keeps coming up in ineffective assistance of counsel claims. Post-conviction relief may be available in some cases, but these claims depend heavily on the facts and have strict deadlines.

The Original Thief Does Not Have to Be Charged

The state does not have to charge or convict the person who stole the property to prosecute a dealing charge. Still, the state must prove the property was actually stolen. If ownership or the theft itself is unclear, that can become a central defense issue.

Common Defense Strategies for Stolen Goods Law Charges

A defense usually starts with the elements the state must prove beyond a reasonable doubt: whether the property was stolen, whether you trafficked in it, and whether you knew or should have known it was stolen. Depending on the facts, a defense may focus on:

  1. Lack of knowledge: You bought the item honestly and had no reason to suspect anything.
  2. No intent to resell: Keeping an item only for personal use generally does not meet the "traffic" definition, though it could still support a theft charge.
  3. Ownership disputes: The state may not be able to show who owned the item or that anyone ever stole it.
  4. Identity and participation: Surveillance footage, pawn records, or co-defendant statements may not reliably tie you to the sale.
  5. Constitutional issues: A court may throw out evidence from an unlawful search or an improper interrogation.

The first-degree charge under Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019(2) adds another element. Prosecutors must show that you initiated, organized, planned, financed, directed, managed, or supervised the theft itself. Simply reselling goods someone else took generally does not meet that provision, which can matter a great deal in plea talks.

๐Ÿ’ก Pro Tip: Do not try to "clear things up" by explaining yourself to detectives or a pawnshop investigator. The state can use even honest explanations to prove the "should have known" element.

Why Acting Quickly Protects Your Future

Early legal help can shape how your case develops. Each State Attorney’s Office sets its own policies on charging decisions, plea offers, and diversion programs. A lawyer who knows how Broward County prosecutors handle these cases may spot chances for a reduced charge or dismissal. Working with an experienced Fort Lauderdale theft lawyer early may keep more options open.

A felony conviction can follow you long after the case ends. It may show up on background checks and block jobs, professional licenses, and housing for years. A conviction also generally makes a record ineligible for sealing or expungement in Florida.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can I be charged if I never sold the stolen item?

Yes, in some cases. Fla. Stat. ยง 812.012 defines "traffic" to include buying, receiving, possessing, or using property with the intent to sell or transfer it. Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019(1) also covers attempts ("endeavors to traffic").

  1. What is the dealing in stolen property definition under Florida law?

Generally, it means trafficking in, or trying to traffic in, property that you knew or should have known was stolen, as described in Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019(1).

  1. Can I be convicted of both grand theft and dealing for the same item?

Generally, no, when both charges arise from one scheme or course of conduct. Under Fla. Stat. ยง 812.025, the state may charge both, but the jury or judge may return a guilty verdict on only one.

  1. Does the person who stole the property have to be caught first?

No. The thief does not need to be charged or convicted for the state to prosecute a dealing charge. The state must still prove the property was stolen.

  1. Is this charge always a felony?

Yes. Under Fla. Stat. ยง 812.019, the offense is either a second-degree or a first-degree felony, depending on the person’s alleged role. The value of the property does not lower it to a misdemeanor.

Protecting Yourself Under Florida Stolen Property Law

The statute reaches further than many people expect. It covers attempted sales, possession with intent to resell, and cases where the state claims you "should have known" something was wrong. Even so, prosecutors must prove every element, and questions about knowledge, intent, and ownership can often open room for a defense. You can read more about Florida stolen property law and related theft issues on our site.

You do not have to face this charge alone, and waiting rarely helps. Reach out to Robert David Malove’s defense team today. Call 954-861-0384 or schedule your confidential consultation to talk through your options with a criminal defense attorney in Florida.

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique, and results may vary. Consult an attorney about your specific circumstances.